How the Substrate Claim Status Agent compares to voice AI callers, EDI-only monitoring, and onshore/offshore teams across speed, cost, data depth, and revenue recovered.
| Attribute | Substrate Claim Status Agent | Voice AI Callers | EDI-Only Monitoring (276/277) | Onshore/Offshore Teams |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Speed / turnaround | Real time - 24/7/365, runs in parallel nights, weekends and holidays | Up to 45 mins per claim. Payer call centers open 9 to 5 | Real-time / instant | ~25–30 checks per FTE/day. Not available nights/weekends/holidays. |
| Cost per check | Usage-based; no per-minute phone cost, no FTE overhead | $5 to $10 per call, regardless of success rates | Cents per transaction | $15.96 per manual check (CAQH); plus hiring, QA, and management |
| Data depth / richness | Combines payor portal check with EDI, EOBs and Appeal Status | Only as rich as what a rep reads aloud | Often generic 277 codes ("see remittance advice"); no denial reason or check # | Dependent on the AR Team/biller's expertise |
| Cognitive load on your team | Low: autonomous; only true exceptions escalate | Medium: manage scripts, callbacks, failed calls | Medium-high: interpret vague codes, chase the rest manually | High: hire, train, QA, backfill attrition daily |
| Throughput / scalability | Highly scalable; more than 50k claims per day. | Limited by payer call center capacity | Highly scalable, but for supported payers only | Scales with headcount/FTEs |
| Payer coverage | 3,500+ payers incl. portal-only Medicare/Medicaid | Any payer with a phone line; quality varies by IVR | ~500 payers support 276/277 | Any payer via phone or portal |
| Reliability / success rate | Documented over >70% success rates | Real-world completion commonly 30–50% | One mismatched input = no usable response | Variable; degrades with fatigue and turnover |
| Actionability | Drives next steps: appeals, rebills & corrected claims. Writes back to your PM | Reports status; some denial follow-up | Reports a code; no next action | Can act, but capacity-limited |
| Integration | Auto-writeback to PM/EHR/data lake; no code required | EHR writeback varies by vendor | Returns X12/JSON; posting often still manual | Manual data entry |
| Modes | EDI, APIs, Payor Portals. Voice coming soon | Voice | EDI | Voice + Portal |
| Ramp / time to value | Days; start from a spreadsheet; no migration | Days to weeks depending on integration | Days | Weeks-to-months to hire, train, reach productivity |
| Audit trail | Screenshots + video of every agent action | Call recordings and transcripts | Transaction logs | Manually entered notes |
See what your claims actually say. Send a file and get a fully worked status report back within 24 hours.
Book a DemoCost and time benchmarks from the CAQH Index: a manual claim status inquiry costs providers $13.80 and takes 25 minutes, vs. $3.64 fully electronic. Denial rework benchmarks from MGMA. Substrate outcome figures are early-adopter results.
Pricing
We believe you should try before you buy. Thats why we publish our price list online, and make it easy for anyone to try.
Start monitoring your no response queues and appeals today. No contract, no setup fee, cancel anytime.
As low as $0.50 / txn
Starts at $2.00 for your first 100 checks each month, then scales down automatically as volume grows.
1 – 100 / mo
$2.00
101 – 1,000 / mo
$1.25
1,001 – 10,000 / mo
$0.75
10,001+ / mo
$0.50
✓
Real-time checks
across 3,500+ payers
✓
Results
pushed to your PM / EHR automatically
✓
Screenshots & audit trail
on every check
For health systems, hospitals, large physician groups and scaled outsourced billers with enterprise needs.
Custom
White glove engagement for large scale healthcare organizations with specialized RCM teams.
Custom
Priced to your committed volume
✓
Volume discounts
for teams with committed volume. Further discounts available as prepaid credits.
✓
SLAs
on turnaround time and uptime
✓
Custom data exports
, including raw payer data & audit trail of agent activity & reasoning.
✓
Additional sources
update claims with data from Lockbox, Correspondences and Clearinghouse Activity (eg rejected claims)
✓
Worklist integration
completion codes mapped to your existing queues
✓
SSO / SAML
for your team
✓
Custom Trends
purpose built analytics and reporting for your organization
Integration options
API
CSV
MCP
SFTP
Custom Feeds
Pay As You Go pricing reflects the rate for your full monthly volume at the applicable tier. Enterprise pricing is available below $0.50 per check for qualifying committed monthly volume.
Is there a minimum commitment? No — Pay As You Go has no monthly minimum and no setup fee.
Do failed or empty checks get billed? No — you're only charged for checks that return a usable result.